It Looks Like You in the Dark
Mathilda Zeller
Hardcover/Trade paperback/Ebook
ISBN: 978-1250402035
Tor Nightfire, October 2026, 288 pgs
If you read Mathilda Zeller’s fantastic short story “Kushtuka” in Never Whistle at Night, then you know what to expect from It Looks Like You in the Dark. Zeller’s short story is the first piece in that anthology, and it perfectly sets the stage for the rest of the book. Never Whistle at Night was a bestseller (which is unusual for an anthology), and raked in a number of awards nods, thanks to the taste of the editors and the talents of authors like Zeller.
You don’t have to have read “Kushtuka” to pick up It Looks Like You in the Dark, but in many ways the novel expands on what the short story set out to do, while giving more room to characters, setting, and ideas. I really enjoyed the short story, but it turns out that Mathilda Zeller is also a seriously strong novelist. It Looks Like You in the Dark is her debut novel, but I’m hoping we’ll see more stories and novels from her.
Zeller starts with a prologue that combines modern and folklore styles of narrative, giving enough to create an image and to allow the reader to develop insights, while sometimes being artfully indirect, especially with true-to-life horrors, letting the reader imagine their own version of terrible events. This section doesn’t just set up the larger narrative perfectly; it also sets the tone, whetting the appetite for what’s to come.
Zeller’s storytelling is a masterclass in nuance and intersections of various kinds of colonialism, including the contrasts between individual perspectives on just about everything. This is brilliantly captured at the outset when the protagonist and her friends encounter a corporate exec who behaves in ways she finds overbearing, but who at least partially enthralls two of her friends. There are elements of different kinds of exploitation at play, as well as the variances in roles and vulnerability as they relate to gender, but nothing is overly simplistic or one sided.
“We didn’t have a hospital or a police station, but we did, somehow, have a Dairy Queen.” As one of the protagonist’s friends excitedly talks about the expansion of nearby rare earth mining, Zeller’s main character gives us this observation. It’s one example of the many meaning-rich passages that allow observant readers to absorb the ironies and contradictions of this (fictional) remote place, carefully alluding to the damage of capitalist priorities and the insidious nature of supposed opportunities, as well as the way colonialism controls people through self-perception and limiting options.
Our protagonist is Tapeesa Filipović. She is smart, fierce, outspoken, loves her hometown more than anything and wants to protect that town and the people she cares about. She is also caught in a confluence of possibilities, which means she has to make decisions about what to do with her present as well as her future. Does she stay and get a job with the mining company, which seems to be offering a sweet deal and a solid future? Does she stay and keep doing the work she is doing, making just enough to scrape by? Or does she do what her Aana wants her to do: get out of town, go to college, and hopefully become one of the actual decision-makers who can impact what happens in small towns like hers? She is relatable, someone we can easily root for, and she provides a wonderful, intricate perspective on everything that happens.
Deceptive modalities of racism and exploitation are front and center and take a range of shapes; all of them will be familiar to marginalized folks who have to deal with these kinds of situations in their lives. In this sense, Zeller is fictionalizing things that are real, describing practices that are ongoing. The corporate execs throw money around and try to gain favor with the locals, even as their statements and actions create a sharp sense of discomfort in Tapeesa. The execs are led by a man who says things like “you’re pretty clever for a village kid”—a classic micro-aggressive backhanded compliment that has its roots in the assumption that village kids are not clever. Importantly, Zeller uses interactions to showcase how different people respond to the efforts of the execs, some siding with them and supporting them, even as Tapeesa registers that the outsiders shouldn’t be trusted. The kid in question, for example, seems to take the phrase as a compliment, not seeing the underlying implications; or, perhaps, being so overwhelmed by the attention of rich people who have experiences beyond the town that he doesn’t care.
But this is part of the point. Things are never easy and obvious to everyone, and when someone offers to change your life, it is painful, delightful, and terrifying all at once, for reasons that are hard to put into a single paragraph. Worse, sometimes you don’t know what their real intentions are until they’ve got you trapped and where they want you. Well—“part of the point” is key here: It would take an entire book to fully dissect everything Zeller’s novel is doing and discussing. That said, she pulls it off seamlessly, and the story itself is never disrupted by delving into the issues at hand.
Meanwhile, as the execs are moving in and swaying the townsfolk, something unsettling is slowly making its presence known . . . something monstrous, maybe even hungry.
Zeller expertly creates a consistent and growing sense of unease while delving into characters as well as personal, local, and community histories. Scenes are occasionally gruesome, as well as occasionally “off screen,” but they are always effective. There’s also a mystery of whether or not the lurking thing is somehow connected to Tapeesa, a story element that Zeller handles well.
Zeller is fluent in conveying a palpable sense of place. Her style is comprised of straightforward but effective language, occasionally delivering wonderful phrasing but without being florid or overwrought. We feel ourselves in this (fictional, albeit inspired by actual locales) place right from the start, and Zeller manages to keep us there, building things with small but distinctive details, until we feel like we’ve been tromping through the cold near her Aana’s home all along. Relationship to place, and the varieties of perspectives on a place, both from without and from within, are central to the book and part of what makes it great.
Complicated family and complicated identity—both personal and collective—are also central to the story. Tapeesa is mixed, and this comes into play, along with the longer history of the town, the occasional influx of outsiders, and the occasional insider venturing out to see the rest of the world. Along with these concepts comes generational trauma, which is handled with precision as part of the makeup of the town and the protagonist, an aspect that is a factor but not a trap for characters, nor the entire story.
An ongoing motif, one that is hard to look at but nonetheless pulled from real life, is an unblinking examination of the ways men exploit or take advantage of women and girls, and specifically the range of ways this takes shape for or impacts those women and girls. As with many of the issues on display throughout the book, Zeller keeps it complex and nuanced, reflecting the prismatic nature of perspectives. That said, the ubiquitous nature of sexual violence shouldn’t be overlooked, and It Looks Like You in the Dark will hopefully not just be mistaken for “setting” or “ambiance” or even “world-building,” but a wake-up call for many readers, a dawning understanding that there is a massive, systemic problem that has yet to be addressed.
Even though Zeller takes on a lot of issues, contradictions and ironies of culture and people are handled beautifully, allowing for complexity without setting aside very justifiable anger. Indeed, anger simmers from the very first page, ever present and subtly driving the narrative, while never overwhelming the story itself. These situations better reflect real communities, as no group of people is a monolith, and everyone’s experiences will inevitably be individual and unique in some ways. Ultimately, at least for me, It Looks Like You in the Dark is an examination of power and power disparity, as well as the importance of decisions and opportunities. There is even a touch of the existential, for those who want to go there.
That said, Mathilda Zeller never forgets that this is a horror novel: The plot is perfectly paced, the story constantly moving, and the horror elements grow in intensity as you turn each page. This book showcases Zeller’s mastery of storytelling, delivering a multifaceted novel without being weighed down or distracted, but rather being rendered more thoughtful and important for the substance at hand. Highly recommended.
Enjoyed this article? Consider supporting us via one of the following methods:








